The Brotherhood of Thieves is a Nantucket staple with over 50 years of history, blending classic pub charm with a multi-level dining and bar experience in the heart of downtown. Downstairs, the 1840s-style whaling pub serves comfort favorites, while upstairs offers a lively surf-inspired restaurant, outdoor patio, and the Notch Whiskey Bar. With everything from burgers and seafood to sushi and craft cocktails, it’s one of the island’s most dynamic spots to eat, drink, and gather.